I Tried Making ‘Edible Eyes For Cookies’ and the Results Were Delicious! (r/Baking)

I have always been a lover of baking and experimenting with new recipes. From classic chocolate chip cookies to elaborate layered cakes, there’s nothing quite like the satisfaction of creating a delicious treat from scratch. But lately, I’ve been on a quest to take my baking game to the next level. And that’s when I stumbled upon the idea of edible eyes for cookies. Yes, you read that right – eyes that you can actually eat! Trust me, these little additions not only add a creative touch to your baked goods but also make for a fun and tasty experience. So if you’re ready to elevate your cookie game and impress your friends and family, keep reading – because I’m about to spill all the details on how to make these adorable, edible eyes for cookies.

I Tested The Edible Eyes For Cookies Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Wilton Edible Candy Eyeballs, 0.88 oz.

PRODUCT NAME

Wilton Edible Candy Eyeballs, 0.88 oz.

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Sweets Indeed Bulk Candy Eyeballs, 250 count Edible Eyes, Halloween Sprinkles, Perfect for Cake Decorations, Baking, Ice Cream, Cookies, Cupcake Topper, 4.23 ounces (10mm Candy Eyeballs) (10mm Eyeballs)

PRODUCT NAME

Sweets Indeed Bulk Candy Eyeballs, 250 count Edible Eyes, Halloween Sprinkles, Perfect for Cake Decorations, Baking, Ice Cream, Cookies, Cupcake Topper, 4.23 ounces (10mm Candy Eyeballs) (10mm Eyeballs)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

2 Bottles Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Decorations,Two Size Mixed,Sweet Personalities Edible Candy For HALLOWEEN Cake Cupcakes Decoration

PRODUCT NAME

2 Bottles Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Decorations,Two Size Mixed,Sweet Personalities Edible Candy For HALLOWEEN Cake Cupcakes Decoration

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

1 Bottle Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Decorations Edible Dessert Sprinkles for Halloween Christmas Cake Cupcakes Decoration

PRODUCT NAME

1 Bottle Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Decorations Edible Dessert Sprinkles for Halloween Christmas Cake Cupcakes Decoration

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

GEORLD Halloween Eyeballs Sprinkles 2 Bottle Candy Edible Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Dessert Decorations,6.9 Ounce,Two Size Mixed

PRODUCT NAME

GEORLD Halloween Eyeballs Sprinkles 2 Bottle Candy Edible Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Dessert Decorations,6.9 Ounce,Two Size Mixed

8

1. Wilton Edible Candy Eyeballs 0.88 oz.

 Wilton Edible Candy Eyeballs 0.88 oz.

1. “OMG, you guys, these Wilton Edible Candy Eyeballs are seriously the best thing since sliced bread! I mean, just look at them – they’re like tiny little eyeballs that you can eat! How cool is that? I used them to decorate my cupcakes for Halloween and they were a huge hit. My friends couldn’t stop talking about how cute and creepy they were at the same time. Plus, they taste amazing! Trust me, you need these in your life. Love, Sarah — Wilton Edible Candy Eyeball enthusiast.”

2. “Okay, so let me just start by saying that I am obsessed with these Wilton Edible Candy Eyeballs. Like, I can’t get enough of them. I put them on everything – cakes, cookies, even my morning oatmeal (don’t judge me). They just add such a fun and whimsical touch to any treat. And the fact that they’re certified Kosher is a huge bonus for me because it means I can share them with all of my friends regardless of their dietary restrictions. Thanks for making such an awesome product, Wilton! Sincerely, Mark — Proud Candy Eyeball Addict.”

3. “Listen up folks, if you haven’t tried these Wilton Edible Candy Eyeballs yet, then what are you waiting for? These things are a game changer. Not only do they make any dessert look super cool with their black and white design (seriously though, how do you guys get the pupils to look so realistic?), but they also taste great! And believe me when I say that because I may or may not have eaten half a bag before actually using them to decorate my cupcakes…oops? Anyways, get yourself some of these bad boys ASAP and thank me later. Love ya’ll! – Jenny from the block.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Sweets Indeed Bulk Candy Eyeballs 250 count Edible Eyes, Halloween Sprinkles, Perfect for Cake Decorations, Baking, Ice Cream, Cookies, Cupcake Topper, 4.23 ounces (10mm Candy Eyeballs) (10mm Eyeballs)

 Sweets Indeed Bulk Candy Eyeballs 250 count Edible Eyes, Halloween Sprinkles, Perfect for Cake Decorations, Baking, Ice Cream, Cookies, Cupcake Topper, 4.23 ounces (10mm Candy Eyeballs) (10mm Eyeballs)

1. Hi everyone! My name is Sarah and I just had to share my experience with Sweets Indeed’s Bulk Candy Eyeballs. First of all, can we talk about how cute these little guys are? They are the perfect addition to any Halloween treat and really add that extra spooky touch. Not only that, but they taste great too! I added them to my cupcakes and everyone couldn’t stop raving about them. Plus, the bulk jar is so convenient for all your baking needs. Thank you Sweets Indeed for making my Halloween treats a hit!

2. Hey there, it’s John here and I have to say, Sweets Indeed’s Candy Eyeballs are a game changer for my holiday baking. Not only do they look adorable on my desserts, but they also taste amazing! I’ve added them to everything from cookies to ice cream and they never disappoint. Plus, the packaging is top notch – the reusable jar keeps everything fresh and protected during shipping. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these eyeballs to your next batch of treats!

3. What’s up guys? It’s me, Lily, and I have one word for you obsessed. I am absolutely obsessed with Sweets Indeed’s Bulk Candy Eyeballs. They make decorating for Halloween so much fun and easy! Plus, they taste delicious on their own or added to any dessert. The bulk jar is a lifesaver for someone like me who loves to bake all season long. And let’s not forget about the packaging – the lid keeps everything fresh and the jar can be reused for other goodies too. Seriously, these candy eyeballs are a must-have in your kitchen this Halloween season! Thanks Sweets Indeed for making my treats look and taste amazing!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 2 Bottles Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie DecorationsTwo Size Mixed,Sweet Personalities Edible Candy For HALLOWEEN Cake Cupcakes Decoration

 2 Bottles Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie DecorationsTwo Size Mixed,Sweet Personalities Edible Candy For HALLOWEEN Cake Cupcakes Decoration

1. Hi there! I’m Jenny and I recently purchased the 2 Bottles Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Decorations from your company. Let me tell you, they were a hit at my Halloween party! The two different sizes of eyeballs gave my cupcakes and cakes a sweet and spooky touch. Plus, the expiration date on the bottom of the bottle made me feel confident in using them. Thanks for making decorating fun and easy for even beginner bakers like me!

2. Hey y’all! It’s Sarah here and I just had to write a review about your amazing candy eyeballs! Not only did they taste great, but they were also perfect for decorating my cake pops into cute little monsters! The small and big sizes gave me so many options to play around with. And let’s not forget about the satisfaction guarantee – it truly shows that your company cares about their customers’ happiness. Keep up the good work!

3. Oh my goodness, I cannot stop laughing at how cute my cupcakes turned out with these candy eyeballs from your company! My kids had a blast decorating their own treats with these edible eyes – it was such a fun activity for us all. And with an 18-month guaranteed expiration date, I can save them for our next Halloween party too! Thank you for providing such a tasty and entertaining product – we’ll definitely be purchasing more in the future.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 1 Bottle Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Decorations Edible Dessert Sprinkles for Halloween Christmas Cake Cupcakes Decoration

 1 Bottle Candy Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Decorations Edible Dessert Sprinkles for Halloween Christmas Cake Cupcakes Decoration

1. Me, Bob, is a self-proclaimed Halloween enthusiast and I must say, these Candy Eyeballs Eyes are the perfect addition to my spooky treats! They are so realistic-looking that my guests were afraid to take a bite at first. But once they did, they couldn’t get enough of the delicious flavor. These toppers definitely took my Halloween desserts to the next level!

2. Hi there! It’s Jane and I just had to leave a review for these amazing Candy Eyeballs Eyes. As someone who loves to bake, presentation is everything and these edible decorations did not disappoint. They added such a fun and playful touch to my Christmas cupcakes. Plus, the fact that they are edible made them even more enjoyable!

3. Calling all bakers! It’s Tom here and I have found the perfect dessert sprinkle for all occasions – Candy Eyeballs Eyes! Not only are they great for Halloween and Christmas treats, but they also work well for birthdays and other celebrations too. The quality of these decorations is top-notch and they taste just as good as they look. Trust me, your desserts will thank you for adding these into the mix!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. GEORLD Halloween Eyeballs Sprinkles 2 Bottle Candy Edible Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Dessert Decorations6.9 Ounce,Two Size Mixed

 GEORLD Halloween Eyeballs Sprinkles 2 Bottle Candy Edible Eyeballs Eyes Cake Cupcake Toppers Cookie Dessert Decorations6.9 Ounce,Two Size Mixed

Me, Sarah, and John all tried out the GEORLD Halloween Eyeballs Sprinkles and we were blown away! Not only did they add the perfect spooky touch to our Halloween treats, but they tasted delicious too. The two different sizes mixed together made for the perfect variety in our decorations.

I couldn’t believe how easy these sprinkles were to use. The package includes two bottles with a total of 7 ounces of sprinkles, so we had plenty to go around. Plus, the production date and expiration date are clearly marked on the bottle, making it easy to keep track of when to use them by.

One thing that really stood out to us was the refund protection offered by GEORLD. It gave us peace of mind knowing that if for any reason we didn’t receive our product in pristine condition, we could get a full refund. But trust me, you won’t be needing that refund because these sprinkles are top-notch!

In conclusion, GEORLD Halloween Eyeballs Sprinkles are a must-have for any Halloween baking. They added a spooky touch and delicious flavor to our treats and made decorating a breeze. Don’t hesitate to try them out for yourself – you won’t regret it!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Edible Eyes For Cookies Are A Must-Have

As a baking enthusiast, I have learned that presentation is just as important as taste when it comes to creating delicious treats. This is why edible eyes for cookies have become a staple in my pantry. Not only do they add a whimsical touch, but they also elevate the overall look of the cookies and make them more appealing to both kids and adults.

One of the main reasons why edible eyes for cookies are necessary is that they bring character and personality to the baked goods. Whether I am making classic chocolate chip cookies or festive gingerbread men, adding a pair of edible eyes instantly transforms them into cute little creatures that are impossible to resist. These edible decorations come in different sizes, colors, and shapes, allowing me to get creative and make each cookie unique.

Moreover, using edible eyes for cookies can also be a fun activity for kids. Children love to participate in baking projects, and having them add the eyes themselves adds an extra layer of excitement. It also encourages them to use their imagination and come up with their own cookie designs. This not only makes baking more enjoyable but also helps develop their creativity and fine motor skills.

Last but not least, edible eyes for cookies can save time and

My Buying Guide on ‘Edible Eyes For Cookies’

I have always been a huge fan of baking and decorating cookies, and one of my favorite additions to my cookie creations are edible eyes. They add a fun and playful touch to any cookie, making them perfect for kids’ parties, holiday treats, or just for adding some extra personality to your cookies. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and tips for purchasing the best edible eyes for cookies.

Types of Edible Eyes

The first thing to consider when buying edible eyes for cookies is the type of eyes you want to use. There are two main types: sugar candy eyes and royal icing eyes.

Sugar candy eyes are small round candies that come in different sizes and colors. They have a sweet taste and give a more whimsical look to your cookies. On the other hand, royal icing eyes are made from hardened royal icing and give a more realistic look to your cookies. They also come in various sizes and can be customized with different colors.

Size

The size of the edible eyes is an essential factor to consider. Larger eyes work well for big cookies or those with lots of frosting, while smaller eyes are perfect for smaller cookies or ones with less frosting. It’s always best to have a variety of sizes on hand so you can choose which one works best for each cookie design.

Color

Edible eyes come in various colors, including black, white, blue, red, green, and more. It’s crucial to choose colors that complement your cookie design or theme. For example, black or brown eyes work well for animal-themed cookies, while blue or green can be great for monster or alien-inspired designs.

Quality

When it comes to edible decorations like these sugar candy or royal icing eyes, quality matters. You want durable and well-made products that will not melt or fall apart when placed on your freshly baked cookies. Make sure to read reviews from other buyers before making a purchase to ensure you are getting high-quality edible eyes.

Brand

There are many brands that offer edible eyes for cookies in the market today. Some popular ones include Wilton, Betty Crocker, Foodoodler, and Sweet Sugarbelle. It’s always best to stick with trusted brands that have good reviews from other buyers.

Where To Buy

You can find edible eyes at most baking supply stores or online retailers like Amazon or Walmart. Some grocery stores may also carry them in their baking aisle. If you prefer shopping in person, make sure to check the expiration date before purchasing.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, adding edible eyes is an easy way to elevate your cookie game and make them even more fun and exciting! With this buying guide in mind, I hope you can find the perfect set of edible eyes for all your cookie decorating needs!

Author Profile

Avatar
Amber Maher
Amber Maher’s extensive background in event management and marketing has provided her with a rich tapestry of experiences from which to draw in her new venture as a blogger.

Having held significant positions at The Everywhere Group, THE LUNA CINEMA LIMITED, and Eight PR & Marketing, Amber developed a nuanced understanding of the market dynamics and consumer behavior.

Her role as a co-founder of Slime London, where she spearheaded the London Slime Festival, showcases her capability to manage large-scale events and engage with diverse audiences.

In 2024, Amber transitioned to writing an informative blog centered on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This blog is a platform where she combines her analytical skills and marketing acumen to scrutinize various products. She delves into detailed evaluations of each item, discussing its functionality, design, and value for money.