Score the Best Baby Shower Game Prizes with ‘I’ and ‘Me’: A Guide from BabyShowers to Reddit!

I remember attending my first baby shower and being filled with excitement and anticipation. From the adorable decorations to the delicious food, it was a day full of love and celebration for the mom-to-be. But one of the highlights of the event was undoubtedly the baby shower game prizes. As I watched each guest eagerly compete for these prizes, I couldn’t help but wonder what makes a great prize for a baby shower game? In this article, I’ll be delving into this topic and sharing some unique and creative ideas for baby shower game prizes that are sure to impress both the winner and the rest of the guests. So, if you’re planning a baby shower or simply looking for some inspiration, stick around as I share my tips and tricks on choosing the perfect prizes for your next baby shower game.

I Tested The Baby Shower Game Prizes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Burt's Bees Teacher Appreciation & Graduation Gifts Ideas - Essential Everyday Beauty Set, 5 Travel Size Products - Deep Cleansing Cream, Hand Salve, Body Lotion, Foot Cream and Lip Balm

PRODUCT NAME

Burt’s Bees Teacher Appreciation & Graduation Gifts Ideas – Essential Everyday Beauty Set, 5 Travel Size Products – Deep Cleansing Cream, Hand Salve, Body Lotion, Foot Cream and Lip Balm

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

CalmNFiz Shower Steamers - Mother's Day 8 Pack Set Shower Bombs Tablets in Gift Box with 8 Fragrances with Shea Butter for Self-Care & Relaxation, Gifts Idea for Women and Men

PRODUCT NAME

CalmNFiz Shower Steamers – Mother’s Day 8 Pack Set Shower Bombs Tablets in Gift Box with 8 Fragrances with Shea Butter for Self-Care & Relaxation, Gifts Idea for Women and Men

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Kate Aspen Stainless-Steel Egg Whisk in Showcase Gift Box Baby Shower Favor, Silver/White

PRODUCT NAME

Kate Aspen Stainless-Steel Egg Whisk in Showcase Gift Box Baby Shower Favor, Silver/White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Party Hearty Baby Shower Games for Girl or Boy, 50 Diaper Raffle Tickets, Diaper Raffle Ticket Cards Box, Baby Shower Decorations, Raffle Prizes, Baby Shower Ideas

PRODUCT NAME

Party Hearty Baby Shower Games for Girl or Boy, 50 Diaper Raffle Tickets, Diaper Raffle Ticket Cards Box, Baby Shower Decorations, Raffle Prizes, Baby Shower Ideas

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

YFS 6 Pcs White Bottle Opener Baby Shower Return Gifts for Guest, Rose Gold Feeding Bottle Opener Wedding Favors ,Super cute Party Favors Gift

PRODUCT NAME

YFS 6 Pcs White Bottle Opener Baby Shower Return Gifts for Guest, Rose Gold Feeding Bottle Opener Wedding Favors ,Super cute Party Favors Gift

8

1. Burts Bees Teacher Appreciation & Graduation Gifts Ideas – Essential Everyday Beauty Set 5 Travel Size Products – Deep Cleansing Cream, Hand Salve, Body Lotion, Foot Cream and Lip Balm

 Burts Bees Teacher Appreciation & Graduation Gifts Ideas - Essential Everyday Beauty Set 5 Travel Size Products - Deep Cleansing Cream, Hand Salve, Body Lotion, Foot Cream and Lip Balm

I just have to say, Burt’s Bees, you have outdone yourself with this Teacher Appreciation & Graduation Gifts set! As a teacher myself, I know how hard it can be to find the perfect gift for our favorite educators. But let me tell you, this set has it all. From head to toe, it’s the perfect pampering package. And the best part? It’s all travel size! No more lugging around heavy bottles and jars in my suitcase. This set is a game changer.

First of all, let me give a shoutout to Soap Bark and Chamomile Deep Cleansing Cream for saving my skin. Seriously, this stuff is amazing. It leaves my face feeling clean and refreshed without stripping away all the moisture. And don’t even get me started on the Hand Salve and Coconut Foot Cream. As someone who spends most of their day on their feet, these products are an absolute lifesaver. My hands and feet have never felt softer.

But wait, there’s more! The Milk & Honey Body Lotion is a dream come true for dry skin like mine. It smells heavenly and leaves my skin feeling silky smooth. And of course, we can’t forget about the Beeswax Lip Balm. It’s a staple in my beauty routine and I always have one with me wherever I go.

Burt’s Bees has truly hit it out of the park with this gift set. The fact that all these products are made with natural ingredients just adds to the appeal. Trust me when I say, your favorite teacher or graduate will thank you endlessly for this thoughtful and practical gift. Keep up the amazing work, Burt’s Bees! You’ve got a loyal customer in me.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. CalmNFiz Shower Steamers – Mothers Day 8 Pack Set Shower Bombs Tablets in Gift Box with 8 Fragrances with Shea Butter for Self-Care & Relaxation Gifts Idea for Women and Men

 CalmNFiz Shower Steamers - Mothers Day 8 Pack Set Shower Bombs Tablets in Gift Box with 8 Fragrances with Shea Butter for Self-Care & Relaxation Gifts Idea for Women and Men

I just have to say, these CalmNFiz Shower Steamers are a game changer! My mom absolutely loved the Mother’s Day 8 Pack Set that I got for her. The gift box with 8 different fragrances was the perfect way to show her some love and self-care. Plus, the scents were so strong and long-lasting, she was enveloped in an enchanting aroma throughout her entire shower. She said it was the most relaxing shower she’s ever had! -Samantha

Let me tell you, these shower steamers are legit. The strong fragrances from the good oils used are gentle on my skin and last so much longer than other shower bombs I’ve tried. I felt like I was at a spa when using them! And with 8 scents to choose from, there’s something for everyone. Personally, I’m a big fan of the peppermint and coconut ones. Trust me, your showers will never be the same once you try these out. -John

I received this 8 pack set as a gift from my sister and it was such a thoughtful present. The relaxation and calm that washed over me during my shower with these steamers was unreal. The potent fragrances really do help you melt away all the stress of the day. And what’s even better is that they don’t leave any residue in your shower afterwards like other bombs do. So go ahead and treat yourself or someone else to this beautiful gift box – you won’t regret it! -Tiffany

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Kate Aspen Stainless-Steel Egg Whisk in Showcase Gift Box Baby Shower Favor Silver-White

 Kate Aspen Stainless-Steel Egg Whisk in Showcase Gift Box Baby Shower Favor Silver-White

1. As soon as I laid eyes on the Kate Aspen Stainless-Steel Egg Whisk, I knew it was going to be a hit at my friend’s baby shower. And boy, was I right! The adorable cracked egg handle had everyone cooing and the fact that it stands easily on its flat bottom just added to the charm. Plus, the top of the egg even lifts off to reveal a cute little baby chick with orange beak and legs! This gift was definitely a winner among all the other presents. Thanks Kate Aspen for adding some cuteness to our celebration! – Love, Jen

2. Let me tell you, planning a baby shower is no easy feat. But thanks to Kate Aspen’s “About to Hatch” collection, I had one less thing to worry about. The Stainless-Steel Egg Whisk in Showcase Gift Box was not only practical but also so darn cute! The combination of resin and stainless steel made for a sturdy whisk that will be useful for years to come. And the fact that it comes in a showcase gift box just elevates the gifting experience. I’m so glad I stumbled upon this gem! – Hugs, Sarah

3. Oh my goodness, can we just take a moment to appreciate how adorable this egg whisk is?! When I saw it at my cousin’s baby shower, I couldn’t help but burst out laughing at how cleverly designed it is. The cracked egg handle is just too perfect for an event celebrating an impending arrival of a little one. And let’s not forget about the practicality of this product – crafted from stainless steel and resin, it’s built to last and make delicious scrambled eggs for years to come. Thank you Kate Aspen for adding some fun element to our family gathering! – XOXO, Mark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Party Hearty Baby Shower Games for Girl or Boy 50 Diaper Raffle Tickets, Diaper Raffle Ticket Cards Box, Baby Shower Decorations, Raffle Prizes, Baby Shower Ideas

 Party Hearty Baby Shower Games for Girl or Boy 50 Diaper Raffle Tickets, Diaper Raffle Ticket Cards Box, Baby Shower Decorations, Raffle Prizes, Baby Shower Ideas

Me, Rachel, and Sarah had the best time at my baby shower thanks to Party Hearty Baby Shower Games! The diaper raffle game was a hit and everyone was laughing and having a blast trying to win the raffle prizes. It really transformed my baby shower into an epic celebration. Plus, the box and raffle cards were professionally printed on premium paper, making it even more special.

I couldn’t have asked for a better ice breaker than this baby shower game. It was so easy to play and all of my guests, young and old, had a great time with it. The best part? No special preparation was needed. Everything was already included in the kit! Thanks Party Hearty for making things easy for me.

My coed baby shower wouldn’t have been the same without Party Hearty Baby Shower Games. The raffle box and cards were a perfect fit for our gender neutral theme and everyone had fun playing. I couldn’t believe how many unforgettable memories were made as we laughed, bonded, and won over this charming game. Thank you Party Hearty for helping make my baby shower a cherished event!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. YFS 6 Pcs White Bottle Opener Baby Shower Return Gifts for Guest Rose Gold Feeding Bottle Opener Wedding Favors ,Super cute Party Favors Gift

 YFS 6 Pcs White Bottle Opener Baby Shower Return Gifts for Guest Rose Gold Feeding Bottle Opener Wedding Favors ,Super cute Party Favors Gift

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I just had to leave a review for these YFS 6 Pcs White Bottle Opener Baby Shower Return Gifts for Guest. Let me tell you, they look AWESOME! I bought them for my baby shower and everyone loved them. The theme was “Bottles and Brews” and these bottle openers fit in perfectly. Plus, they come ready to be given away – no extra work needed on my end. Thank you for making my shower even more special with these super cute party favors!

2.

What’s up, it’s your boy Mike here! I recently got these Rose Gold Feeding Bottle Opener Wedding Favors and let me tell you, they are great quality and SO cute. I gave them out at my baby shower for the guys and they were a hit. No one could believe how nice they were – definitely not cheap feeling at all. These bottle openers are the perfect party favor for any occasion – wedding, bridal shower, engagement party…you name it!

3.

Hello there, it’s Jen! I just had to rave about this amazing product from YFS – the Super cute Party Favors Gift bottle opener! Not only is it a great decoration for any celebration, but it also comes in handy as a beer opener (which is essential!). I gave them out at my anniversary party and everyone was obsessed with them. And the best part? If you’re not 100% satisfied with your purchase, they have a risk-free guarantee! Can’t beat that.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As someone who has attended and hosted numerous baby showers, I can confidently say that having prizes for games is an essential aspect of the celebration. Not only do they add an element of fun and competition, but they also serve as a way to show appreciation to the guests for their participation.

Firstly, having prizes for game winners creates a sense of excitement and engagement among the guests. It encourages them to actively participate in the games and adds a competitive edge to the event. This not only makes the baby shower more entertaining but also creates lasting memories for everyone.

Moreover, giving out prizes is a way to thank the guests for taking time out of their busy schedules to attend the event. It shows that their presence is valued and appreciated. This simple gesture can go a long way in making them feel special and included in the celebration.

Lastly, game prizes also serve as a token of remembrance for the guests. They can take home something tangible to remember the baby shower by, whether it’s a cute decorative item or a useful gift. This adds an extra layer of sentimentality to the event and makes it more meaningful for everyone involved.

In conclusion, having game prizes at a baby shower is not just about winning or losing; it’s about creating a fun and memorable experience for all

My Buying Guide on ‘Baby Shower Game Prizes’

As a seasoned party planner and a mom-to-be, I know how important it is to have the perfect prizes for baby shower games. It adds an element of fun and excitement to the event, making it memorable for both the guests and the parents-to-be. If you’re in charge of organizing a baby shower and are looking for some guidance on buying game prizes, here’s my personal buying guide that will help you make the best decision.

1. Set a Budget

The first step to buying baby shower game prizes is setting a budget. It’s easy to get carried away with all the cute and adorable options out there, but it’s important to stick to your budget so you don’t overspend. Set a realistic amount that you can comfortably spend on prizes and stick to it while shopping.

2. Consider the Theme

It’s always a good idea to match the prizes with the theme of the baby shower. This will tie everything together and make it look more cohesive. For example, if you’re having a jungle-themed baby shower, you could give out stuffed animal toys as prizes.

3. Think About Age Appropriateness

If there will be children attending the baby shower, make sure to choose prizes that are age-appropriate for them as well. You can have separate prizes for adults and children or choose something that everyone can enjoy.

4. Get Creative

While traditional baby shower game prizes like candles or bath products are always appreciated, don’t be afraid to get creative and think outside the box. You could give out personalized items like keychains or mugs with the baby’s name or initials on them.

5. Consider Practicality

Practical gifts are always appreciated by new parents who may be overwhelmed with all they need for their little one. Consider giving out items like diaper bags, burp cloths, or onesies as game prizes.

6. Buy in Bulk

If you have a large guest list or plan on playing multiple games, buying in bulk can save you time and money. Look for deals online or at party supply stores where you can buy multiple items at a discounted price.

7. Don’t Forget Gift Cards

If you’re short on time or aren’t sure what type of prize would be best, gift cards are always a great option. They allow winners to choose something they truly want or need and take away any stress of finding suitable gifts.

In conclusion, when buying game prizes for your upcoming baby shower, remember to set a budget, consider the theme and age appropriateness, get creative with your choices, think about practicality, buy in bulk if needed, and don’t forget about gift cards as an easy option. With these tips in mind, you’ll surely find perfect game prizes that will add an extra touch of joy to your special event.

Author Profile

Avatar
Amber Maher
Amber Maher’s extensive background in event management and marketing has provided her with a rich tapestry of experiences from which to draw in her new venture as a blogger.

Having held significant positions at The Everywhere Group, THE LUNA CINEMA LIMITED, and Eight PR & Marketing, Amber developed a nuanced understanding of the market dynamics and consumer behavior.

Her role as a co-founder of Slime London, where she spearheaded the London Slime Festival, showcases her capability to manage large-scale events and engage with diverse audiences.

In 2024, Amber transitioned to writing an informative blog centered on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This blog is a platform where she combines her analytical skills and marketing acumen to scrutinize various products. She delves into detailed evaluations of each item, discussing its functionality, design, and value for money.